The Reading Bud

Book Blog by Heena Rathore-Pardeshi

Book Review: B&G Mystery: We Can’t Tell You by Josh Martin

Book Details:

Author: Josh Martin
Release Date:
January 27, 2025 
Series: B&G Mystery: We Can’t Tell You (Book 1 of 3)
Genre: Horror, Mystery, Supernatural, Psychological Thriller
Format: E-book 
Pages: 107 pages
Publisher: –
Blurb:
Have you ever awoken from a deep sleep and still feel like you’re dreaming? A few minutes of confusion is certainly common…..
But what about several months?
Not so common, unfortunately.
One day, not quite a year ago, it happened to me. I couldn’t shake the feeling. I could remember, and not remember, all at the same time.

Confused? Yeah, I was too….
Still am, as a matter of fact.
That one morning changed everything. I mean everything. Nothing could have prepared me for the events that followed.
Prepare yourself….
You’re about to see why.

Review

Rating: 4 out of 5.

B&G Mystery: We Can’t Tell You by Josh Martin is an ambitious and unsettling thriller that begins in the quiet of a Wisconsin morning but quickly spirals into a labyrinth of déjà vu, cryptic notes, phantom figures, and rules that seem to govern fate itself. Told through the eyes of a seventeen-year-old whose memory and reality keep splintering, the novel places readers in the same disoriented state as its protagonist, never sure whether he is awake, dreaming, or being manipulated by forces beyond comprehension.

The book’s strength lies in its atmosphere. From the very first pages, the story is drenched in dread. The text messages, the mysterious trio in the woods, the near-death experiences at intersections, and the omnipresent feeling of being watched create a constant sense of unease. Symbolism is cleverly threaded throughout, providing narrative cohesion even when the plot itself veers into deliberate chaos.

I must point out that the narrative often undermines itself with repetition. Tension that should build steadily sometimes loops back on itself, making the pacing sag in the middle chapters. Yet when the book works, it works brilliantly. The closing chapters bring together many of the scattered clues and escalate the narrative into cosmic horror, suggesting that the story is not merely about one boy’s fractured reality but about humanity itself being manipulated, collected, and used.

We Can’t Tell You Part 1 is a bold, eerie, and at times brilliant psychological thriller that thrives on atmosphere and symbolism. It is a gripping, confusing, and unforgettable experience that lingers long after the last page, even if the reader is left with more questions than answers.


You can also read this review at:

Goodreads


Amazon


One response to “Book Review: B&G Mystery: We Can’t Tell You by Josh Martin”

  1. Book Review: We Can’t Tell You: Part II (B&G Mystery: We Can’t Tell You Book 2) by Josh Martin – The Reading Bud Avatar

    […] no answers. From the very first pages, the book continues the claustrophobic dread established in Part I, and amplifies it with a sense of inevitability: the sense that Grayson is not just walking into […]

    Like

I love reading your comments, so please go ahead…

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

I’m Heena

Welcome to The Reading Bud, my cosy corner of the internet dedicated to all things books and authors. Here, I invite you to join me on a journey of discovering under-represented books, independent and small press authors, and all things book with a touch of love and loud purrs. Let’s get Reading!

Book of the Month

Read this captivating story on the adventures and hardships of Frank Knightlite, a man who strives to illuminate darkness with his lantern in search of answers to life’s questions.
You can get it here.
August 2025
M T W T F S S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Reading is like breathing to me.

Recent Posts

  • Book Review: The Trail Of The Beast (The Deschembine #2) by Matt Spencer

    Author: Matt SpencerRelease Date: 13th May 2019Genre: Urban FantasySeries: The Deschembine Trilogy (Book #2)Format: E-book Pages: 362 pagesPublisher: Back Roads Carnival Books Blurb: Five years ago, Rob and Sally fled Brattleboro, Vermont. Now married, they are hiding out in a Florida backwater, hunted by…

  • Book Review: Mainely Power (A Goff Langdon Mainely Mystery #1) by Matt Cost

    Author: Matt CostRelease Date: 18 September 2020Genre: Cosy MysterySeries: Goff Langdon Mainely Mystery: Book #1Format: E-book Pages: 304 pagesPublisher: Encircle PublicationsBlurb:Was Harold Dumphy killed to cover up something at the nuclear power plant he was the head of security at? This is what…

  • RMFAO October’20 Buddy Read Book Selection

    So we are planning to have a buddy-read over at RMFAO, my Goodreads Book Club. It will be a month-long buddy read and we have some really great book options to select from. For the month…

  • Book Review: Marilia, the Warlord (Chrysathamere Trilogy #1) by Morgan Cole

    Author: Morgan Cole Release Date: March 2020Genre: YA Fantays, Coming Of AgeSeries: The Chrysthamere Trilogy: Book #1Format: E-book Pages: 482 pagesPublisher: Blurb: Formerly published under the title “Marilia, the Bastard.”Born the bastard daughter of a painted lady, Marilia was told she would live out…

  • Book Review: The Shoreless Sea (Liminal Sky #3) by J. Scott Coatsworth

    Author: J. Scott CoatsworthRelease Date: 9th September 2020Genre: Science-Fiction Fantasy, LGBTQSeries: Liminal Sky (Book #3)Format: E-book Pages: 400 pagesPublisher: Dreamspinner PressBlurb:As the epic trilogy hurtles toward its conclusion, the fight for the future isn’t over yet. It could lead to a new beginning,…